How much should I pay for a decent mattress?

Short answer: $2,000 to $3,000 for a queen-size mattress in Australia. Under $1,000, you're buying foam that needs replacing in three to six years. Over $4,000, you're usually overpaying for a brand name rather than better parts.
How Much Should I Pay for a Mattress

In the $2,000-$3,000 price bracket, there are three things that are worth holding out for:

  • Quality materials. Natural latex or high-density foam over a real spring unit, with densities and spring counts published where you can read them.

  • Spring tension matched to your body weight. One firmness sold to every body is the biggest reason people end up uncomfortable.

  • A modular design. Parts you can swap, so soft springs in year eight don't mean a whole new mattress.

How to work out a mattress's cost per year

Divide the price by the years you'll realistically get out of it. That one sum changes what "expensive" means.

Mattress Price Realistic lifespan Cost per year
Cheap spring mattress $500 4 years $125
All-foam bed-in-a-box $1,250 6 years $208
Pocket springs with natural latex $2,450 20 years $123

The cheap mattress and the good one cost about the same per night. One of them just takes the money in a lump. Heavier sleepers should shade those lifespans down, since more body weight compresses foam faster.

What drives mattress cost: materials, labour and marketing

Materials are the biggest chunk. Natural latex, micro springs and a high pocket spring count are expensive. We put 986 pocket springs in a queen where a lot of companies use under 768, as well as using GOLS-certified organic latex.

Labour is next. A slab of foam in a cover takes minutes. A hand-stitched and assembled mattress takes experienced people and costs a lot.

Marketing is where the gap between companies gets wide. Bed-in-a-box brands that run social media campaigns and physical ads spend a lot of money. These costs get absorbed by the consumer, at the cost of quality components.

Returns cost companies a lot. Sell a single firmness spring to every body shape, and customers will find it too soft or too firm. A returned mattress goes to landfill. The more returns a company has, the more these costs are passed on to the consumer.

We handle it differently. Because our mattresses are completely modular, when a mattress feels too firm or too soft, we can swap the springs or the latex until it's right, rather than taking the whole thing back, and two swaps are free during the 7-month trial. Lower costs are absorbed into the price of our mattresses, as well as less waste.

What you get at each price point

Below are the price categories for a queen-size mattress, which is what most Aussies buy.

Queen price What's usually inside Likely lifespan
Under $800 Bonnell springs or low-quality polyfoam, thin cover, no firmness options 3-6 years
$800-$2,000 Bed-in-a-box territory. Entry-level pocket springs or thick memory foam, one firmness per model 5-8 years
$2,000-$3,000 Higher spring counts, natural latex or high-density foam, spring tension matched to your weight, replaceable parts 10-20 years
$3,000+ Either genuinely good materials or a brand name. Both look identical on the ticket Depends entirely on what's inside

Under $800 is guest room territory. On a tight budget, a basic pocket spring mattress outlasts a soft foam one every time.

From $800 to $2,000, you're mostly into bed-in-a-box brands, some decent, though almost all companies make one firmness and hope it suits everyone.

The $2,000-$3,000 bracket is where you will find high-quality materials. Two mattresses at $2,500 can be built completely differently, so this is where understanding specs and materials pays off. Our own queen mattresses all sit within this range: Cooper $1,950, Aurora $2,450, Cloud $2,950. The higher price is due to using 5cm of natural latex, 7-turn body-weight matched pocket springs, and micro springs (perfect for side sleepers).

Mattress types

Polyurethane foam mattresses

$400-$1,500. Standard polyfoam, no springs, cheap to make and cheap to ship, which is why it fills the bed-in-a-box market. Density is the number to ask for. Anything under 30kg/m³ softens within a couple of years, and you'll feel the dip well before the warranty is halfway through.

Keep in mind: A solid block of foam gives heat nowhere to go. All-foam mattresses are the hottest.

Memory foam mattresses

$800-$10,000+. Memory foam uses oils and chemicals to increase the viscosity of the foam. That's the sink-in feeling - they soften under body heat and return to shape slowly. Some people love the feeling of memory foam, and others think it feels like quicksand.

Memory foam also stores roughly 70 times more heat than air by volume, so 25cm of it with no springs sleeps hot. Expect five to seven years before it dips. More detail in my memory foam vs latex comparison.

Keep in mind: Many proprietary memory foams and "gel" foams claim to have cooling technology. I have debunked a few of these claims in my article on mattress marketing gimmicks.

Cheap innerspring mattresses

$400-$900. Bonnell or continuous coils, all wired together, with a thin layer of foam over the top. When your partner rolls over, the whole bed knows about it. They come in one firmness, the foam flattens fast, and there's nothing to replace when it does. Fine for a guest room, hard to justify for a bed you sleep in every night.

All-latex mattresses

$2,000-$5,000. Latex all the way down, no springs. Durable and expensive, and worth clearing up one myth: a 25cm slab of latex is still 25cm of foam. Latex handles heat better than memory foam or polyurethane does, but the amount of foam matters far more than the type. It's why at Ausbeds we use 5cm of natural latex over springs instead of a mattress made entirely of it.

Natural or synthetic latex changes the price too: natural comes from rubber tree sap and lasts longer; synthetic is petroleum-based and cheaper. The Dunlop or Talalay process shifts feel and cost again.

Premium hybrid mattresses

$1,500-$5,000+. Quality foam or latex over a pocket spring unit. This is what a good mattress is, and it's most of what's worth buying once you're past the cheap end.

The springs do the work. They hold you up, they let air move through the bed, and their tension can be matched to your body weight. The comfort layer only has to take the edge off. Ask for spring count and wire gauge, because that's where the money goes: we use 986 pocket springs in a queen where a lot of companies use less than 768.

Four things to check before you spend the money

1. Read the specs. Ask for foam density in kg/m³, spring count and comfort layer thickness. If a company won't give you numbers, that silence is the answer.

2. Ask what happens when the foam or springs wear out. In most mattresses, the answer is that you buy another one. Ask whether components can be replaced individually and what each costs. At Ausbeds, every component can be bought individually – cover, springs, micro springs, latex, foam.

3. Check the sleep trial. We run a 7-month sleep trial with free component swaps. Most discomfort is a firmness problem rather than a mattress problem. Read the warranty too: ten years against manufacturing faults is not ten years of guaranteed comfort.

4. Look at your bed base first. When someone tells me their mattress is sagging, it's the base about 80% of the time. Press down on your slats. If they flex under hand pressure, a new mattress sinks into that shape within months. Sort the bed base out first, or you'll blame the wrong thing.

How much to spend on a mattress

People walk into my showroom having spent wildly different amounts on their last mattress. At one end, $900 on an all-foam Koala. At the other, north of $8,000 on a Tempur.

The $800 buyers almost always bought on convenience. It suited the budget, an Instagram ad turned up at the right moment, and the box arrived two days later. The $8,000 buyers bought on the opposite logic, where the price and the material science were the proof. Something that expensive had to sleep better.

Both types of customers end up with an Ausbeds once they understand the quality of materials we were using and the philosophy behind the mattress design.

That's the answer to the question. Around $2,000 to $3,000 for a queen, spent on materials you can name and parts you can replace. What you spend matters far less than knowing what it bought.

People also ask

About the author

Karl from Ausbeds

Karl is the owner of Ausbeds. He started the company after realising how many people were frustrated by mattresses that failed too soon and too often. So he built a workshop in Sydney and began making mattresses the way they should be made - with transparent materials, adjustable designs, and customer-first thinking. When he's not in the showroom/workshop, he's on Reddit, Whirlpool, and OzBargain, cutting through industry fluff with honest mattress advice.

You might also like